Note: I wrote this essay in 2001 for English 120 at the College of the Bahamas. It was published the following year in the course booklet as a “Sample Informal Argumentative Essay.” The essay has some baby fat that needs cutting, and I hope to get to that later, but I offer it here as a quick read that encapsulates most of my ideas about culture.
Has Wendy’s started selling ‘conch snacks’, you ask? How can an American fast food chain ever possibly hope to be considered Bahamian? While I agree that the idea may sound shocking, I believe that because of its importance in the lives of Bahamians today, it is possible to say that Wendy’s is just as Bahamian as Bamboo Shack. But before I explain my position, allow me to clarify a point: when I say Wendy’s, by extension I’m referring to the other major fast food restaurants such as Kentucky Fried Chicken (KFC), and McDonalds. It naturally follows that by referring to the Bamboo Shack I can be making reference to any well-known Bahamian Restaurant, like Castaways, Dirties or The Palm Tree.
The first objection any red-blooded Bahamian would raise about the above claim would be the menu. Obviously the food that these fast food restaurants serve is not considered traditional “Bahamian cuisine”. You cannot, and probably never will be able to, go into a Wendy’s and order a conch snack, or go to McDonalds and order a dish of sheep-tongue souse. However, the questions I ask are these: is the food served the only test of Bahamian-ness’? Just because something is not indigenous to the Bahamas, can it be considered Bahamian? Are there any other factors that contribute to something’s being considered Bahamian, or a part of Bahamian culture?
For the purpose of our discussion, it would help to have a clearer definition of “culture”. Patricia Glinton-Meicholas in her essay “Uncovering the Bahamian Self”, defined culture as “the sum of the historical and physical experiences of a people, and how they interact to create endemic group attitudes and behaviors.” What this means is that culture is a fusion of a peoples’ history and how they as a people have coped with that history. Or, put another way, culture is created by people surviving and reacting to their environment. So, despite what Bahamians in general may think “their culture” is, it really is a dynamic fusion of past and present that does not remain static. It is constantly evolving taking into account the complete environment that makes up the modem Bahamas and our reaction to that environment, including the general lifestyles that we as a people lead.